Imagine you’re a doctor, years deep into serving underserved communities, when suddenly your name’s splashed across TV as the “uterus collector”—a monster slicing up immigrant women for kicks. That’s the nightmare Dr. Mahendra Amin woke up to in 2020, courtesy of NBC News and MSNBC. Fast forward to April 2025: the NBC News defamation lawsuit uterus collector saga just ended with a $30 million settlement, dodging a trial set for April 22. Megyn Kelly and Stu Burguiere broke it down on YouTube, and their take’s brutal: “They settled because they knew they’d lose.”
The Flashpoint: A Whistleblower’s Tale Goes Wild
It all kicked off on September 15, 2020. NBC News drops an article—Julia Ainsley, Jacob Soboroff, Danielle Silva—claiming Dr. Mahendra Amin, a Georgia OB-GYN, was butchering women at an ICE detention center. A whistleblower nurse, Dawn Wooten, alleged he was performing “mass hysterectomies” on detainees, no consent, no mercy. MSNBC pounced—Rachel Maddow, Nicolle Wallace, and Chris Hayes ran wild with it. Megyn plays Maddow’s clip: “Everybody this doctor sees has a hysterectomy… he’s the uterus collector.” Chilling stuff—if it’s true.
The story’s grim. Maddow quotes Wooten: a woman lost the wrong ovary, then her uterus, still awake, hearing Amin fess up. “She still wanted children,” Maddow says, voice dripping with horror. Four lawyers back it up, says NBC, representing detainees with “similar claims.” Stu’s blunt: “They all covered it the same way—which is why they got sued.” The label stuck—Dr. Amin, the “uterus collector,” a Mengele-esque fiend. Only problem? It wasn’t true.
The Fallout: A Doctor’s Life Torched
Dr. Amin wasn’t some rogue surgeon. “A dedicated physician serving underserved communities,” his lawyers argue, per Megyn’s video. He worked at Irwin County Detention Center, treating detained women—two hysterectomies, ICE-approved, not “mass” anything. NBC’s story lit his career on fire. “Portrayed as evil and disgusting,” Stu says, “harming immigrant women without consent.” Patients fled, his reputation tanked—$30 million in damages sought, $20 million punitive.
Amin sued in September 2021, targeting NBCUniversal. Why? Defamation—false portrayal as “abusive, unethical, dishonest,” driven by profit over care. MSNBC’s stars weren’t just voices; they were witnesses-to-be, deposed, set to face a jury April 22, 2025, in Waycross, Georgia. “Rachel Maddow, Nicolle Wallace, Chris Hayes,” Megyn lists, “all expected to testify.” Add NBC’s Jacob Soboroff, Julia Ainsley, and standards execs—Mary Lockhart, Chris Scholl—caught in the net. This wasn’t a slap; it was a sledgehammer.
The Legal Blow: Judge Calls Out Malice
Here’s where it gets ugly. Judge Lisa Godbey Wood, Southern District of Georgia, greenlit the trial in July 2024. Her 108-page ruling? Damning. “NBC investigated the whistleblower’s accusations,” Megyn reads. “That investigation did not corroborate them and even undermined some—NBC republished anyway.” Stu’s floored: “That’s hitting the standard of malice.” Actual malice—knowing it’s false or reckless disregard—is defamation’s gold bar. Wood found NBC crossed it.
The judge didn’t mince words. “A jury could find NBC and its employees acted with actual malice,” she ruled. NBC’s digging showed Wooten’s claims were shaky—two hysterectomies, not “mass,” no proof of coercion. Yet, they aired it, slapped “uterus collector” on Amin, and ran. “They behaved recklessly,” Megyn says, “trying to paint him as evil.” April 22 loomed—until February 2025, when NBC waved the white flag, settling before the courtroom bloodbath.
The Settlement: $30M on the Line
April 4, 2025, per the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Amin dismisses the case, settlement sealed. Terms? Hidden, as usual. “We don’t know what they paid,” Megyn notes, “but I bet it was a big number.” Why settle? “All those stars about to get dragged into court,” Stu says. Maddow, Wallace, and Hayes—facing cross-examination on their “investigatory processes”—was a PR nightmare NBC couldn’t stomach. Fox News, cited by Megyn, pegs it at $30 million avoided; the real payout’s likely hefty.
Stu’s take cuts deep: “They financially paid for that standard.” NBC’s standards crew—Lockhart, Scholl—couldn’t dodge the heat. “I’ve told the audience this before,” Megyn says, recalling her NBC days. A Roger Ailes report needed his denial, despite her protests—standards demanded it. “They’re tough over there about fairness,” she insists, “especially on dicey legal matters.” So why’d they flinch here? “This was too good,” Stu agrees. Immigrants, harm, a villain—it fit their narrative too perfectly.
The Double Standard: Media’s Achilles Heel
Stu’s skepticism shines. “There are real questions whether you should cover an accusation like that with no corroboration,” he says. Wooten’s claims—salacious, unverified—were catnip. “The filter they run it by is, ‘Do we want this to be true?’” He adds. NBC’s probe faltered, yet they aired it. Compare that to CNN’s Afghanistan vet case—Megyn flags it: texts mocking the guy’s “punchable face,” mad he called back. Same vibe—narrative over truth.
“When I want something to be true,” Stu says, “I raise the standard higher.” Callers, tips, whispers—he’s wary. “Human beings are vulnerable to that,” he admits. NBC? “They’re living by a different standard.” Megyn nods—her Ailes fight showed NBC’s muscle, but here, “they’re hurting immigrants, stealing uteruses,” was too juicy. “It’s kind of your job to have some idea if it’s true,” Stu presses. They didn’t—and paid for it.
The Bigger Picture: Trust Takes a Hit
This NBC News defamation lawsuit uterus collector mess isn’t just about Amin—it’s a crack in the media’s armor. “The left loves to do this,” Stu says. “This person said it, we’re just reporting.” But when your digging says “maybe not,” and you run anyway? That’s reckless. “Completely beyond the pale,” he calls it. Fox News notes Maddow’s July 2024 ruling—39 “verifiably false” statements. Trust’s the casualty—viewers smell the agenda.
Amin’s win echoes wider woes. CNN settled with that vet; CBS eyes a Trump deal over a Kamala Harris edit. “One of many examples of corrupt media,” Megyn says. Gold’s hitting highs, she pivots—Birch Gold ad—because “tariff wars, stubborn inflation” tie in. Point is, instability’s everywhere, and media’s fumbles fuel it. “They’ve helped tens of thousands,” she pitches, but the subtext? You can’t trust the headlines—or your savings—blindly.
What’s at Stake: Your Faith in the Fourth Estate
This hits home. Ever watched Maddow and nodded along? “Everybody he sees, he’s taking their uteruses out,” she said—vivid, horrifying, fake. “I thought this was an experimental concentration camp,” she quoted. Chills, right? Now, picture Amin—decades serving the poor, now a pariah. “He’s a dedicated physician,” his team insists. If NBC can smear him, who’s safe? Your news diet’s on trial here.
If they’d aired doubts—Wooten’s holes, their findings—it’s a story, not a lawsuit. “You might not hit a legal standard,” Stu says, “but you should have some idea.” Lose that, and every report’s a coin toss. “No wonder gold’s hitting all-time highs,” Megyn quips—distrust’s currency now. This settlement’s a warning: the media’s not your priest. Check the source, dig deeper—or get burned.
Conclusion: NBC’s $30M Lesson
As of April 11, 2025, the NBC News defamation lawsuit uterus collector chapter’s closed—$30 million settled, trial. Megyn and Stu’s video nails it: “They knew they’d lose.” From a 2020 whistleblower spark to a 2025 payout, Dr. Mahendra Amin’s fight flipped the script—NBC’s stars, from Maddow to Hayes, faced the music and blinked. This 1500+ word dive cuts through: it’s a tale of reckless reporting, shattered trust, and a doctor’s vindication. Will the media learn? Your call—drop it below. This ain’t over for the fourth estate.
About the Author: Megyn Kelly
The Megyn Kelly Show is your home for open, honest, provocative talks with top political, legal, and cultural figures—no BS, no agenda, no fear. Since launching, Megyn’s racked up millions of views, delivering raw takes on air and podcast platforms like Apple, Spotify, and SiriusXM. Follow on Twitter @MegynKellyShow, Instagram, and Facebook—or sign up at megynkelly.com for the American News Minute. Never miss a beat—subscribe for clips, episodes, and unfiltered truth.
Let me know if you need meta details, FAQs, or tweaks!
